You waited years for this matchup: WoW: The War Within vs. FFXIV: Dawntrail. Two flagship MMOs dropped tentpole expansions just weeks apart in 2024, and you felt the hype everywhere, on Twitch, in Free Company chats, in guild Discords. But with limited time (and a single sub budget), which new expansion actually won 2024? Here’s a clear, grounded breakdown, what they promised, how they landed, and where your time is best spent.

The 2024 Expansions at a Glance

Release Timing, Platforms, and Pricing

Dawntrail launched first: early access on June 28, 2024 and full release on July 2 for Windows, macOS, PS4/PS5, and Xbox Series X

|

S (the Xbox debut hugely broadened reach). The War Within followed with early access on August 22 and full release on August 26 for Windows and macOS.

Pricing leaned in different directions. Dawntrail’s expansion was $39.99, with the usual Final Fantasy XIV subscription tiers (Entry at $12.99/month, Standard at $14.99). WoW’s The War Within was pricier upfront, $49.99 base, $69.99 Heroic, and $89.99 Epic, on top of the $14.99/month sub. If you’re price-sensitive or multi-sub juggling, that spread mattered.

What Each Expansion Promised

Dawntrail positioned itself as a fresh start: a vacation-turned-adventure in Tural, a level cap raise to 100, two new jobs (Viper and Pictomancer), a sweeping 7.0 graphics overhaul, and a gentler narrative tone after Endwalker’s cosmos-spanning drama. It also stressed accessibility, Duty Support across more dungeons and broader platform support.

The War Within framed itself as chapter one of the World of Warcraft “Worldsoul Saga.” It bet big on evergreen systems: Warbands (account-wide progression), Hero Talents (class identity without button bloat), Delves (instanced, scalable adventures), and Skyriding available broadly from the start. Blizzard promised a more connected endgame loop and fewer borrowed-power headaches.

Storytelling, Worldbuilding, and Art Direction

Narrative Tone and Payoffs

You come to FFXIV for story, and Dawntrail stays true to form, with a twist. It opens lighter: sun, festivals, and friendly rivalries before the plot sharpens into political stakes across Tural. Some of you felt the first hours meandered: others loved the breather after Endwalker. The emotional payoffs still land, and the character work remains consistently strong. If you play MMOs for narrative arcs and companion moments, Dawntrail speaks your language.

The War Within swings darker and more subterranean, literally. It pulls you into Khaz Algar and the Nerubian underworld, nudging at mysteries seeded for years. The pacing is tighter than Dragonflight’s early campaign, and the thematic setup for the full Worldsoul Saga feels deliberate. You’ll get fewer big tear-jerker moments than FFXIV, but more forward momentum and clear hooks for the next chapter.

Zones, Dungeons, and Music

Dawntrail’s Tural is vibrant and distinctive, sun-baked cityscapes, jungle plateaus, and aquamarine coasts, with Soken’s score doing Soken things: theme leitmotifs that burrow into your brain after a single dungeon run. The dungeon art pops, and the boss designs push readability first, spectacle second.

War Within’s zones lean moody and layered. From the dwarven heritage touches to the chitin-and-shadow Nerubian spaces, art direction is confident, with Blizzard’s usual skybox flexes. The soundtrack is grander and broodier than Dragonflight, with percussive cues that sell the descent underground. Dungeon readability is improved over some of DF’s early outliers, telegraphs are clearer, palettes less punishing on the eyes.

Core Gameplay and Endgame Loops

Raids, Dungeons, and Group Finder

Dawntrail’s raid cadence kicked off with The Arcadion (Normal) shortly after launch and Savage soon after. Encounters continue the modern FFXIV design ethos: puzzle-forward mechanics and strict execution checks that reward pattern recognition. Duty Finder/Party Finder remains the gold standard for smooth matchmade and organized content, with cross-data-center options keeping queues healthy.

The War Within launched with the Nerub’ar Palace raid and a refreshed Mythic+ pool. If you crave progression and competition, WoW still owns the Race to World First spectacle and the weekly M+ push routine. The Dungeon Finder and Group Finder tools aren’t as frictionless for new players as FFXIV’s, but they’re powerful once you’re in a guild or community.

Open-World Systems and Progression

Delves are War Within’s swing at flexible endgame: short, scalable adventures you can knock out solo or with friends. They’re snackable in the best way and slot nicely between raid nights and Mythic+ keys. Warbands make alting less of a chore, with account-wide reputations and collections smoothing the friction that had piled up over expansions. Skyriding gives you Dragonflight’s kinetic movement nearly everywhere, and it still slaps.

Dawntrail, meanwhile, sticks to FFXIV’s proven loop: MSQ anchor, roulettes for daily tomestones, crafting/gathering depth if you want it, and scheduled raid/trial drops. Where it innovates is polish, Duty Support for more dungeons makes the main story smoother to solo, and horizontal goals (glamour, housing, relics as they roll out) keep you engaged without forcing a grind.

Jobs/Classes and Balance

Dawntrail’s new jobs are crowd-pleasers. Viper scratches the stylish dual-blade itch with satisfying flow, and Pictomancer is a playful caster with clear visual language. Balance at launch leaned safe, FFXIV tends to avoid wild outliers, but minor potency passes followed quickly. The broader job ecosystem remains approachable without sacrificing ceiling.

WoW’s Hero Talents are the marquee update. They add flavorful branches, think identity-forward bonuses and synergy, without bloating bars. Early tuning had a few spikes, as usual for WoW launch seasons, but weekly adjustments brought specs into a healthier spread. If you love tinkering with builds and squeezing another percent from logs, WoW remains the sandbox you min-max in.

Onboarding, QoL, and Technical Polish

New/Returning Player Experience

If you’re returning or brand-new, Dawntrail is easier to slide into. You can story your way through with NPC allies, avoid social friction while learning mechanics, and catch up with clear gear ladders. The Xbox release also matters, you can play on a couch with parity to PC.

The War Within made smart strides. Warbands reduce the “oh no, I picked the wrong main” anxiety, and Delves give you meaningful solo content at max level. If you left during Legion/BfA and hated borrowed power or cloak/essence chores, you’ll likely appreciate the cleaner approach here.

UI/UX Improvements and Performance

FFXIV’s 7.0 graphics update is the headline: better materials, lighting, and character models, all while staying performant on PS5 and modern PCs. The UI saw subtle quality-of-life improvements, and controller support remains best-in-class for MMOs.

WoW continues to be remarkably scalable. Even on older hardware, you’ll hit stable frame rates with sensible settings. The UI revamps from Dragonflight carry forward, and The War Within adds more native conveniences, reducing addon dependency for basics. Launch stability for both was solid overall, with the usual day-one congestion spikes but quick recovery.

Value, Monetization, and Community Sentiment

Subscriptions, Cash Shops, and Grind

WoW’s higher box price plus the WoW Token and a robust services shop means you feel the monetization more. It’s not pay-to-win, but the Token blurs lines in a way some players dislike, especially around boosting and economic balance. The upside: you can effectively fund your sub with gold if you’re industrious.

FFXIV keeps its cash shop mostly cosmetic with optional skips. You’ll still see premium mounts and outfits, but there’s no Token equivalent. Progression is time-based and predictable, weekly caps, clear catch-up windows, and fewer fear-of-missing-out traps. If you hate feeling nudged by monetization, Dawntrail is the calmer lane.

Reviews, Player Metrics, and Cultural Buzz

Sentiment in 2024 was close. Dawntrail’s early hours sparked debate (“too slice-of-life?”) but critics and players largely praised its worldbuilding, jobs, and the graphical upgrade. The Xbox launch created fresh buzz and noticeably healthier queue times across data centers.

The War Within earned strong marks for leveling, dungeon design, and the return-to-form systems philosophy. Delves and Warbands resonated with lapsed players. Competitive scenes, from Race to World First to high-key Mythic+, kept WoW in headlines through the season. If your social circles care about esports-style progression, WoW owned more of that mindshare.

The Verdict: Who Won 2024?

Best for Competitive Progression

Pick The War Within. Between a tightly tuned first raid tier, the Mythic+ treadmill, and buildcraft with Hero Talents, WoW gives you a clear ladder to climb every week. The ecosystem around it, logs, add-ons, race events, makes improvement addictive and measurable.

Best for Story-First and Casual Play

Choose Dawntrail. The MSQ flow, Duty Support, and Xbox availability mean you can enjoy the ride without social pressure. The graphics update makes Eorzea feel new again, and the job roster is welcoming if you’re swapping roles.

Our Overall Winner

For 2024, the edge goes to Final Fantasy XIV: Dawntrail.

Here’s why. Dawntrail broadened access in tangible ways (Xbox, Duty Support expansion), refreshed the entire game’s look, and delivered a confident, if lighter, story that most of you praised by the end. Its monetization stayed the course, and its day-to-day loop respected your time. The War Within is excellent, arguably WoW’s most player-friendly foundation in years, but Dawntrail moved the needle for more kinds of players and felt like a generational step forward.

Conclusion

So, WoW: The War Within vs. FFXIV: Dawntrail, who won 2024? If you chase parses, love a weekly climb, and want that high-stakes race energy, you’ll be happiest in Azeroth. If you want a beautiful world, story-led play, and a steady, respectful progression path, Tural is calling. Either way, you’re walking into a great year for MMOs. And if you can swing it, sample both: clear Dawntrail’s MSQ at your pace, then jump into WoW’s Delves and Mythic+ for a different flavor of mastery. Not a bad problem to have.